When is Sharing Your Work Academic Misconduct?

University of Twente Logo

At the University of Twente in the Netherlands, a student has been cleared of academic misconduct by the school’s Examination Appeals Board for sharing her work with other students.

The original board that reviewed the case found that she had shared her work with several other students ahead of a submission deadline. The lower board found that this amounted to academic misconduct by “allowing others to copy during assignments.”

The recommended penalty was a warning that would have resulted in a note on her academic record. She appealed that decision to the university-wide board, which overturned the lower board’s decision.

According to the upper board, they were bound by a 2018 ruling by the national CBHO, a now-dissolved governmental body that oversaw disputes between students and universities, including academic misconduct cases. In that ruling, the CBHO said, “Merely making one’s own work available to another person is far removed from what is generally understood as fraud in everyday language.”

According to the student, she expressly told the other students that they were not allowed to copy her work and that her intent was simply to help the other students. However, the lower board still found that she had “knowingly and deliberately” shared her work for the purpose of enabling plagiarism.

So this raises an interesting question: When is sharing your work academic misconduct? Sadly, there is no clear answer to that question.

Muddied Waters

Schools want to keep a balance between allowing students to help each other and discouraging academic misconduct. This is why schools often offer tools such as tutors, writing centers and peer review sessions to help those struggling with their work.

However, help can easily cross the line into academic misconduct. For example, a writing aide may so fundamentally change a student’s paper that it’s more their work than the student’s. There’s also a fine line between helping students work through a problem and giving them the answer.

To make matters worse, AI has not helped the situation. As part of Google’s classroom AI push, the company has launched “Guided Learning” an AI tool that is supposed to help students learn without just giving them the answer. But many, understandably, feel that it still crosses a line.

And why wouldn’t they? These waters have been muddied for decades by sites that, despite being clearly designed to help students cheat, claim that their essays or answers are “for educational purposes only” and that they only provide “homework help.” Such phrases are practically slogans for sites such as Chegg, which itself has (or had) become a synonym for cheating.

While I agree that the student’s intentions should be examined, doing so is incredibly difficult. These waters have been deliberately muddied by bad actors. Telling people that essays or answers aren’t to be used for cheating is so often said with a wink and a nod that they can sound meaningless.

So, schools have started to judge more on actions than intentions. That, in turn, is what happened here. The instructor and the lower panel became aware of the student’s actions and decided that her stated intentions were irrelevant. The upper board disagreed.

I don’t really find fault in either board’s decision, especially with the CBHO setting a national precedent. But that doesn’t change the fact that what the student did was unwise, even if it was well-intentioned.

My Advice to Students

One thing that’s not known from the article is whether any of the other students who had access to the work actually copied it. If they did, that’s clearly academic misconduct, either plagiarism or collusion depending on your view, and they should have to face consequences for that.

Still, while I understand students wanting to help each other and wish that desire could be rewarded, doing so is very risky in this current climate. I would not share my work, past or present, with other students and I would not reuse work in future assignments.

If you are in a situation where you are considering doing that, I would speak with the instructor or one of the class proctors before doing so. Let them know what is going on, what your intentions are and why you wish to do it. They may discourage you from doing it and offer alternatives. This way, even if you do move forward with it, they will have known in advance, which is much better than finding out after the fact.

If you are a student struggling with your work, I would encourage you to seek out official school resources. This can include speaking with your instructor, visiting the student help center or using a school-provided tutoring service. While these tools can have their own issues, you’re much less likely to be judged harshly for using them.

If this all sounds familiar, it’s because “Be cautious, communicate with your instructor and use school resources” is my stock advice for students when it comes to academic misconduct. The goal isn’t to win an academic misconduct battle as this student did, it’s to never have one in the first place.

Bottom Line

In the end, I don’t take much issue with either board’s decision. I can understand why the lower board found against the stduent and was going to issue a relatively light penalty. I can understand why the student disagreed with that finding and appealed. I can see why the upper board found in favor of the student.

I don’t think anyone was objectively unreasonable in this case and I agree that the CBHO precedent should be the final word on the matter.

But for students, this case is a warning. Good intentions don’t always matter. If you want to help your fellow students, do so in a way that is both ethical and safe. Don’t share your work. There are other, better options available.

By all means, be helpful. But don’t be reckless. Don’t endanger your academic career to help someone else. You can’t help others if you aren’t in a good place yourself. That is as true in academia as it is in life in general.

Want to Reuse or Republish this Content?

If you want to feature this article in your site, classroom or elsewhere, just let us know! We usually grant permission within 24 hours.

Click Here to Get Permission for Free