Slovakia’s Spy Chief Accused of Plagiarism

Earlier this week, The Slovak Spectator (SME) reported that Pavol Gašpar, the country’s Intelligence Director, plagiarized his 2011 bachelor’s thesis at the Pan-European University in Bratislava. Ironically, the thesis is entitled, “Criminal Aspects of the Penalty of Corruption.”
According to SME, two-thirds of the paper was plagiarized from four separate sources. Two of those sources were not cited at all. This includes the first chapter of the thesis, which was allegedly copied from a 2008 article by Pavol Augustín in the journal Policajná Teória a Prax. The last chapter was likewise plagiarized, this time from a 2009 article by Renáta Kravcová.
Another 24 pages were allegedly copied from Ožef Čentéš’s The Fight against Corruption in the Slovak Republic and the European Union and Ondrej Samaš’s annotated Criminal Code.
However, despite the high level of unattributed copying, the Pan-European University has defended the thesis, saying that it “was prepared under the guidance of an experienced supervisor, received a positive review from an opponent, and was defended before a commission as part of the state final exam.”
Gašpar also denied the allegations, saying that his work is in order and that he will “not comment further on the lies of SME, which gives its readers incomplete and misleading information in order to manipulate public opinion.”
The instructor who oversaw the thesis has not provided a comment.
The allegations come at a difficult time for Gašpar. He is already under suspicion of corruption as a former police officer testified he paid Gašpar €60,000 ($70,000) for information. He was also recently involved in a car accident that raised more suspicions about his assets and income.
However, if history is anything to go on, it’s unlikely that this plagiarism story will impact Gašpar. After all, the country recently had another high-profile plagiarism scandal that similarly went nowhere.
A Rough History
Disclosure: I do not speak Slovak, so I have not personally reviewed any of the documents. Likewise, much of this information is based on either secondary source English articles or automated translations of news articles.
Slovakia, like many Eastern/Central European countries, has had recurring issues of high-profile political figures facing plagiarism allegations. This includes Romania, Germany, Austria and Hungary, to name a few.
This isn’t even the first recent scandal in Slovakia. In July 2020, the nation’s then-Prime Minister, Igor Matovič, was accused of plagiarizing his 1998 master’s thesis from Bratislava’s Comenius University. Once again, the case involved entire pages and charts.
However, in this case, Matovič admitted to the plagiarism, and the school confirmed that it was an issue. Despite that, he refused to step down and easily survived a no-confidence vote, with only 47 of 125 lawmakers voting against him.
He ended up resigning nine months later, following a separate scandal over his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic and a secret deal to buy Russian vaccines. He was later appointed Minister of Finance. His degree was not revoked.
And that represents a significant problem for critics of Gašpar. Even in a situation where both the graduate and the university acknowledged the plagiarism, there were no significant repercussions. With both Gašpar and his former school rallying around him, there’s even less likelihood.
Understanding the Problem
Over the past year, I’ve spoken extensively about the dark ages of academic plagiarism. It was a time period in which the internet was widely available (especially in schools), but citation norms had not yet caught up, and plagiarism detection tools were not yet widely available.
I typically pin that time period between the late 1990s and the mid-to-late 2000s. That would put Gašpar’s thesis at least slightly outside that time period. However, that takes a very English-centric viewpoint.
Slovak, like many other languages, lagged behind English in terms of support from plagiarism-detection tools. Although I am unsure when Turnitin added the Slovak language, a 2013 paper notes that it had not yet included “Advanced support for the Slovak language.”
In short, Gašpar’s case, much like Matovič’s, falls in that “dark ages” time period. A time in which internet research (and thus copying) was easy to do but difficult to detect.
As such, it’s perfectly understandable how, despite the widespread copying, this slipped through the cracks at the time. What is more worrisome is how the scandals are being handled after the fact.
Matovič did not face any consequences for his actions, and it’s unlikely that Gašpar will either. Matovič’s school at least investigated the allegations but ultimately took no action. Whether this was a legal limitation or a choice by the school is unclear. Either way, he still has his degree and wasn’t even required to redo the thesis.
In Gašpar’s case, it’s even worse as the school is openly defending him despite credible allegations of plagiarism. This gives the school the appearance of being tolerant of plagiarism and lacking a genuine commitment to preserving academic integrity.
Usually, I would say that this tarnishes the school’s reputation and harms legitimate students who are working hard to earn their degrees. However, Slovakia is a small enough country (with just over 5 million inhabitants) that it can actually harm the entire country’s reputation in higher education.
For many, this and Matovič’s case may be the only things people hear about Slovakian universities. It doesn’t leave a good impression if, in both cases, the story ends with the plagiarist getting away scot-free.
Bottom Line
The past year and a half has been a particularly ripe time for politically motivated plagiarism scandals, particularly in the United States. This includes the spate of DEI-related allegations in the United States, Presidential candidate Kamala Harris and allegations against the Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, to name a few.
While politically motivated plagiarism scandals can be legitimate, most of the dialogue is dominated by supporters and opponents, either trying to minimize or inflate the severity of the plagiarism.
As such, one’s feelings about a particular plagiarism scandal likely have more to do with their political views than their stance on plagiarism.
However, the allegations against Gašpar are specific and worrisome. They allege that a significant percentage of the work was copied verbatim, and two of the sources were not cited at all. They further allege plagiarism of footnotes and other material in the thesis.
Even if this is only partially true, it still represents a significant portion of the work and raises questions about Gašpar’s scholarship.
The university’s response only extends those questions to the school itself.
After all, if the school cares this little about the allegations about Gašpar, then one has to wonder what else they are permitting? In my experience, most plagiarists don’t plagiarize just once. Likewise, most schools that tolerate plagiarism don’t tolerate it just once.
In addition to wondering if this is a pattern for Gašpar, we must now also wonder if it’s a pattern for the school. Sadly, the people hurt most by that are the legitimate students who are just trying to get an education.
Want to Reuse or Republish this Content?
If you want to feature this article in your site, classroom or elsewhere, just let us know! We usually grant permission within 24 hours.
