3 Count: Questions of Impartiality

Have any suggestions for the 3 Count? Let me know via Bluesky, Mastodon or LinkedIn.

1: Democrats Probe DOJ’s Role in OpenAI Copyright Fight

First off today,Sara Fischer at Axios reports that congressional Democrats are circulating a letter intended to be sent to Attorney General Todd Blanche, expressing concerns about the Department of Justice’s perceived lack of impartiality in the copyright dispute between OpenAI and The New York Times.

The New York Times is suing OpenAI for alleged copyright infringement. The newspaper claims that OpenAI unlawfully used its content to train various AI models, including ChatGPT. As part of that case, the DOJ submitted a brief supporting OpenAI and opposing the Times’ claims.

The letter, which is already signed by various Democratic lawmakers, expresses concerns that the United States Copyright Office and United States Patent and Trademark Office were not consulted before the DOJ filed its brief. It also expresses concerns that the DOJ’s brief was biased, despite the organization being required to be impartial.

2: ‘Time for Action’: Germany and 10 Other EU Countries Urge New Copyright Rules in the AI Age

Next up today, Luca Bertuzzi at Euro News reports that 11 EU countries have drafted a letter asking the European Commission, the EU’s executive body, to propose new legislation to better protect cultural and creative industries from AI.

The countries involved include Germany, Spain, Poland, Austria, Cyprus, Croatia, Denmark, Estonia, Portugal, Slovakia and Slovenia. They note that AI has gone from a research novelty to a commercial application in just a few years. However, they worry that AI has been built with little regard for copyright law and the humans whose work was used to train the models.

The Commission is scheduled to present a legislative package on digital issues in the second quarter of 2027. However, it is unclear what that package will contain. It’s worth noting that the EU already has a copyright directive in place that lets creators opt out of having their work used to train AI systems. However, in its current form, the directive is almost impossible to enforce.

3: Ye Settles Alice Merton Copyright Lawsuit Over Rejected Sample

Finally today, Camila Curcio at Law Commentary reports that Ye, formerly known as Kanye West, has reached a settlement with Alice Merton over the alleged unauthorized use of a sample from Merton’s song “Blindside.”

According to Merton, she was contacted by Ye’s representatives about using a sample from her song in Ye’s 2023 song “Gun to My Head.” However, Merton, a Holocaust survivor, rejected the idea due to antisemitic comments made by Ye. Nonetheless, she alleges that Ye used her sample in early versions of the track that were publicly performed and that it appeared briefly in a released version of the song.

The settlement follows a ruling by the judge that rejected Ye’s motion to remove references to his antisemitic comments from the case. The judge found that the comments were relevant to the case. Shortly after that, both sides announced a settlement, with the case being dismissed without prejudice until the settlement is finalized.

The 3 Count Logo was created by Justin Goff and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License.

Want to Reuse or Republish this Content?

If you want to feature this article in your site, classroom or elsewhere, just let us know! We usually grant permission within 24 hours.

Click Here to Get Permission for Free